Choice Closure

Today’s newsletter is sponsored by BugHerd


Imagine this…

You and your partner decided to splurge on a fancy meal.

The host seats you at your table. It’s outside next to a tree lit up with small fairy lights.

This place is dreamy.

You open your menu and quickly find there are 3 different dishes you’d love to try.

“Oh man,” you think, “this is a tough choice.”

You ponder between your options for another minute.

Finally, you decide to go with the shrimp pasta dish. The side of garlic bread is really calling your name.

You close your menu and sit back in your seat.

Your mind switches gears from weighing the options of the different dishes to enjoying the ambiance around you.

What’s making you feel so relaxed?

In today’s edition of Why We Buy, we’re taking a look at Choice Closure—why physically closing something makes us feel like we can move on from the decision-making part of our purchase.

Let’s get into it…

Reclaim 2-3 Costly Hours of Follow-up Time with BugHerd!

BugHerd is the world’s leading tool for streamlined client feedback, better QA, and faster web development. Join 350,000+ BugHerd users and save costly time-consuming admin work!

“BugHerd has instantly added to our productivity and our clients are very impressed. It saves communication time, back and forth and frustration with crazy documents with revisions. It has been a game changer for our agency”

– Jonathan Bradford, MD – Kota Agency

BugHerd can help you:

 Save 2-3 hours with actionable website feedback.

• Streamline client communication, enhance collaboration.

 Centralise feedback for better project visibility.

The Psychology of Choice Closure 🧠

When faced with a few different choices, the physical act of closing something makes us feel more confident that we made the right choice.

A London Business School 2013 study asked participants to choose 1 tea to drink from a menu of 24 options.

  • Participants couldn’t change their minds once their order was placed.
  • Half of the participants had to close their menu after they’d ordered. The other half were allowed to keep it open.
  • Participants drank their tea, then rated their satisfaction with their flavor selection.

Those forced to close their menu were more satisfied with their tea than those allowed to keep their menu open.

The physical act of closing their menu created Choice Closure.

These participants felt like the decision-making experience was over.

They could focus on the tea-drinking experience (without creeping feelings of doubt telling them they’d made the wrong choice).

Inside Your Buyer’s Mind🧐

Your buyers are often faced with endless choices.

They need to evaluate many different options, make trade-offs, and decide which product is right for them.

After they make the purchase, they’re often left with a burning question, “Was this the right choice?”

Without Choice Closure, your buyers’ minds can spiral into a vortex of “what ifs…” that leaves them questioning their decision. 🌪️

Instead of being excited about their new purchase, they’re distracted by all the options they 
didn’t choose and worry they’ve made a mistake.

To nip that analyzation in the bud, you need a physical act of closure that stops the decision-making part of their mind and sparks the enjoyment part.

And yes, you can create Choice Closure with digital products and experiences, too. Here’s how. 👇

How To Apply This 🤑

Alright, so how can we apply this right now to sell more?

Design your choice set strategically

If you can make people feel confident in their choice you can avoid post-purchase regrets.

The Economist makes it obvious which subscriber pricing is the best by making all of the options the same price.

Subscribers can pay $6 for just the print magazine or just the digital magazine.

Or, they can pay $6 for print AND digital.

It’s a no-brainer. This decision leaves buyers feeling positive about their decision without the need for a physical act of closure.

Create a moment of change between the buying experience and customer experience

How can you create a transition moment that makes buyers feel differently after they’ve made the purchase?

For brick-and-mortar stores, the physical act of going up to the cash register creates the Choice Closure.

But for online stores and digital products, it’s a bit trickier.

Here are a few digital-friendly ideas:

  • Change the colors you use before the purchase vs. after the purchase to create two distinct experiences for buyers (while remaining on brand).
  • Ask your buyers to answer a question that makes them feel like they’re in a new experience now that they’ve bought your product.
  • Make them feel like they’ve entered into a new experience by changing who your communications are from or giving them special access to something that makes them feel like they’re now an insider.

Help online buyers visualize their post-purchase experience

Write your calls to action to showcase the metaphorical transition from buying to bought.

Use this button as the act of closure. Mentally your buyers feel like they’re in a new experience once the button is clicked.

It’s like they’re closing their menus and ready to put all their focus on enjoying the tea they just ordered.

Masterclass could create choice closure by updating their CTA button.

Instead of saying “Start Learning,” they could say “Enter Your New Classroom.”

Even though it’s a digital experience, the thought of entering a new classroom creates a vision in the buyer’s mind of themselves walking out of the room they’re currently in.

This creates Choice Closure and helps them transform into their new identity: the person who learns highly sought-after skills from experts.

The Short of It 💥

Creating Choice Closure isn’t just for brick-and-mortar stores or physical products.

There are ways to help online buyers feel a sense of post-purchase completion too.

Help your buyers close the door on the decision making experience.

And show them how to open the *new door* to their product experience.

Until next time, happy selling. 




Wanna really get inside your buyer’s head?

There are a few ways I can help:

  1. Get explosive clarity about what works with buyers by learning how to conduct 1:1 Clarity Calls (3200+ happy students)
  2. Learn how to mine online reviews from real buyers to generate ideas and copy that converts (500+ happy students)
  3. Book a 1:1 strategy call with Katelyn and get the answers you need to get unstuck and move forward with confidence
  4. Apply to sponsor an upcoming issue of Why We Buy (next opening in June)

Thank you to our featured sponsor

Written By Katelyn

Katelyn Bourgoin is the CEO of Customer Camp, a 4X founder, and a cheese lover. She lives by a simple mantra: whoever gets closer to the customer wins.

Related Posts

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation Bias

Let’s explore Confirmation Bias – why we seek out information that confirms what we want to believe.

Growth Flywheels

Growth Flywheels

Let’s explore Growth Flywheels—why the most successful businesses in the world use them to grow smarter (instead of harder).

Empathy Gap

Empathy Gap

Let’s explore Empathy Gap—why we often underestimate how much a buyer’s emotional state can influence their behavior and decisions.

The Labor Illusion

The Labor Illusion

Let’s explore The Labor Illusion—why we may value something more when we think it requires a lot of effort.

Regret Aversion

Regret Aversion

Let’s explore Regret Aversion – why we make choices to avoid regret.

Pratfall Effect

Pratfall Effect

Let’s explore the Pratfall Effect—why imperfections can actually make people like you (or your brand) more.



Let’s explore Gong—the company that harnessed customer interactions to become the undisputed leader in revenue intelligence.

Generation Effect

Generation Effect

Let’s explore the Generation Effect—why we remember something more if we put effort into generating it.



Let’s explore Mascots—why we love and buy from brands that use mascots.

Nostalgia Effect

Nostalgia Effect

Let’s explore the Nostalgia Effect—why we spend more when we remember our past.





Wanna get inside your buyer’s head? Join our newsletter and get one customer psychology tip delivered straight to your inbox each week. It’s like a 2-min workout for your brain.

You're in. Giddy up! 🤠

Become the go-to customer EXPERT

If you can figure out what makes people tick, click and buy, you can make bank

We’re often asked if we offer a certification program teaching our in-depth research methods. The answer is… not yet. But we’re working on it.

Want first dibs when we launch our new certification program? Jump on the waitlist.

You're in. Giddy up 🤠


Wanna get inside your buyer’s head? Join our newsletter and get one buyer psychology tip delivered to your inbox each week. It’s like a 2-min workout for your brain.

You're in!


If you can figure out what makes people tick, click and buy, you can make big $$$. We're working on a new research certification program. Want first dibs when we launch it? Hop on the waitlist.

You're in!


Wanna get the buyer insights you need from key stakeholders (and look like a boss)? Our new Stakeholder Mining Kick-off Session training is coming soon. Join the waitlist to get first dibs.

You're on the waitlist! We'll reach out soon!


Wanna get the buyer insights you need from key stakeholders (and look like a boss)? Our new Stakeholder Mining Kick-off Session training is coming soon. Join the waitlist to get first dibs.

You're in!